
Beyond the Protocols
Students do not reside in the research.
We must and we should use
Evidence-based practices and materials,
But they do not always work.
In fact, research demonstrates,
For a certain percentage of the class,
It is reasonable to expect science will fall short.
There are stories outside of the science,
The stories, as frustrating as they are,
Keep us sharp and motivated
In our own learning.
Kristen
She wasn’t getting it.
Reading was not ringing true.
She was doing the work,
Plodding and consistent.
Improvement, nevertheless, was static.
So, I moved beyond the protocol.
I asked her to read the passage again.
And then again.
And then one more time.
Once more for good measure.
Five repetitions? Not in the protocol!?!
The unexpected, but hoped for, happened.
She sat up and stared at me with
Eyes exploding in a smile.
She got it! She felt the magic.
All the pieces fell into place,
And she experienced the author’s message.
The story became hers.
More than fluency.
More than comprehension.
She owned that message.
Suddenly the science became relevant.
Improvement was steady and marked.
Kristen became not just a student.
She became a learner.
Karen
Never a great student.
Always a slow reader.
Now a new Mom.
Impatient to finish high school
Karen saw no connection between
Education and her new responsibility,
Raising her son.
Dutifully, performing her reading task,
Karen, read “little” as “small”
With no awareness of this mistake.
An error? Yes.
But was it really?
Today, I decided not.
She understood, after all.
Protocols directed the check mark.
My heart said otherwise.
Ignoring errors of no consequence,
Going beyond the protocols,
Karen began to read differently;
She read for ideas.
Empowered with new determination,
She unveiled a new source,
Her own mind,
And the images she created.
A tool for comprehension
And importantly, for self-confidence.
Words sourced by an author and
Ideas powered by her mind.
Fostered by commitment to her son,
Teachers registered,
More work with better quality.
Karen became excited.
She had something new to offer
That little one of hers.
Freshly inspired, she declared,
With conviction never before experienced,
“My son will be a reader!”
Protocols
What about the protocols?
Learn them. Use them.
They keep us consistent.
They keep us honest.
But protocols are limited.
They do not tell the whole story.
They don’t tell a story at all.
There is something,
Something magical,
Beyond the protocols.
Students live in their stories.
Teach with protocols,
And learn their stories.
Trust your professional judgment.
Trust yourself.
Trust your heart.
Respect the protocols,
And listen to the student.
Love the student.








